Grimm Reviews – “The Lambkin and the Little Fish”

My introductory post.  

Grimm Reviews List 1

Grimm Reviews List 2

Grimm Reviews List 3

“The Lambkin and the Little Fish”

There were a brother and sister who loved each other dearly.  Their mother was dead, and they had a step-mother who did not like them.  One day, as the two were playing with other kids around a pond that came up to the house, the step-mother – who knew about witchcraft – bewitched them turning the brother into a fish and the sister into a lamb.

Time passed, and then one day visitors showed up at the house.  The step-mother told the cook to kill the lamb for their guests.  The cook got the lamb, but then he saw a fish swimming in the pond.  He heard the two talk of how sad they were, so he killed another sheep and fed it to the guests and took the lamb and fish to a “good peasant woman.”

This peasant woman was the foster-mother of the girl, and took them to a wise woman who blessed the lamb and fish so they returned to their human form.  The wise woman then took them to live alone – but happy – in a hut in the forest.

#

What did the other kids do when their playmates turned into a fish and a lamb?

What did their father do?  Did he never ask what happened to his kids?

Why a fish and a lamb?

If you can turn unwanted kids into fish and lambs, why wait to … destroy the evidence?

Wait, the girl had a foster-mother?  A foster-mother who didn’t take the kids back once they were human again? 

Wait, this evil step-mother turns these kids into a fish and lamb and thinks she’s had the lamb killed, and she gets away with it?

What was the point of this story?

Grimm Reviews – “The Old Woman in the Wood”

My introductory post.  

Grimm Reviews List 1

Grimm Reviews List 2

Grimm Reviews List 3

“The Old Woman in the Wood”

A family was traveling by carriage through a forest when they were attacked by robbers who killed everyone except a serving girl who hid behind a tree.  The girl wandered looking for a road to lead her out of the forest since nobody lived there.  When evening came she sat down under a tree and resolved to just wait for whatever. 

Not long after that, a dove flew to her with a little, golden key in its beak.  It told her that it would unlock a tree where she would find food.  The dove brought a second key to a second tree where she would find a bed to sleep.  The next morning, the dove brought a third key to a third tree where she would find clothing more splendid than had by any princess.  The girl lived there for some time, with the dove bringing keys to unlock trees for whatever she needed.

Eventually, the dove asked for a favor.  It wanted the girl to go to a house of an old woman.  The girl was not to speak to the woman and only pass her on the right.  In the house was a room filled with rings of gold and jewels.  Among them is a plain ring.  She was to find this plain ring and return it to the dove.

The girl went to the house and didn’t speak to the old woman.  This upset the woman who tried to stop the girl, but the girl rushed into the room filled with rings.  While she’s looking for the plain ring, she notices the old woman was trying to leave with a bird cage.  The girl went after her and found that the bird in the cage had the ring.  The girl grabbed it and ran back to the dove.

But the dove didn’t show up.  Instead one of the trees turned into a handsome prince.  The old woman was a witch who had turned him into a tree, but for two hours a day he could be a dove.  All of his servants and horses had also been turned into trees, and they all returned to their original form.  The prince and the girl married and lived happily ever after.

#

Wait, they were going by carriage through a forest without a road?  Why?

I didn’t know trees came with locks.

“I’ll turn you into a tree … and for two hours a day you can be a dove.” Why?

Why trees?  More importantly, why trees with locks hiding closets and bedrooms?  What was the importance of the plain ring?

Why did the prince tree/dove wait to ask the girl to break the spell and not, you know, the day after she showed up?

Grimm Reviews – “The Poor Miller’s Boy and the Cat”

My introductory post.  

Grimm Reviews List 1

Grimm Reviews List 2

Grimm Reviews List 3

“The Poor Miller’s Boy and the Cat”

There once was a miller who had three apprentices.  One day he told them that whoever brought him the best horse would get the mill because the miller wanted to retire. 

The three lads went out, but the older two told the youngest – Stupid Hans – to just wait because he’d never find a horse.  But he went with them.  The three came to a cave and laid down to sleep, but once Hans was asleep, the other two left him there.

When Hans woke up, he ran out into the forest and came across a cat, which told him that if Hans served her for seven years, she would give him the most beautiful horse.

So Hans followed her to her castle where all her servants were cats.  They were all happy cats who jumped around and played music while they dined.  After dinner, the main cat asked Hans to dance with her, but he said no because he didn’t know how.  So she sent him to bed.

Hans worked for the cat by chopping wood, mowing her meadow, and building her a small house.  He did all these with tools of silver and gold.  The seven years passed like six months.

When it was time for him to leave, she opened the door of the house to show twelve of the best horses.  She said that the horse wouldn’t go with him, but that she would follow him in three days with it. 

So Hans went back to the mill with his old, dirty clothing.  The other two apprentices were there, but one was blind and the other lame.  They laughed when he said a horse would follow him in three days.

Hans was so dirty they didn’t want him in the mill, so he had to sneak into the goose house to sleep.  He woke three days later, and a coach with six horses appeared along with a seventh for him.

In the coach was the cat, who was in reality a beautiful princess.  She asked about the boy, and learned he was in the goose house.  She had her servants clean him and present him.  She then asked what horses the other apprentices had brought, but neither had found one.  When Hans’ horse was brought forward, the miller was overjoyed. 

The miller was all set to give Hans the mill, but the princess took him in the coach.  They returned to the little house he had built, only it was now a wonderful castle full of gold and silver items.  They married and lived happily ever after.

#

Is this the same Stupid Hans from “The Griffin,” or are people named Hans normally stupid?

A horse?  That’s what the miller wanted so he could retire?  Not jewels, or gold or anything.  Just “My mill, for a horse.”

The time in this story confuses me.  Was it seven years, or six months?  If Hans was just going to sleep for three days, why not just make it that the horse would follow him the next day and he’d only have to sleep for one night?  But more importantly, if someone sends you out to find a horse, they probably expect you back in a few days or maybe a week.  But seven years? 

What happened to the other two apprentices?  What stories do they have?

Why was the princess a cat?  I feel like we’re missing a story.

This is one of the “Huh?” stories.