Monday, May 29, 2017

Grimm Reviews – “The Three Little Birds”

“The Three Little Birds”

One day a king and his entourage went out on a hunt.  They rode past a hillside where three sisters were watching their cattle.  The oldest pointed to the king and said if she didn’t have him, she’d have none.  Her two sisters followed with two of his ministers.  The king heard this and had the three brought to his castle.  Since they were all beautiful, the king and his ministers married them.

Sometime later, the king left on business and asked the sisters to stay with the queen, who was about to give birth.  She gave birth to a boy who “brought a bright red star into the world.” The two sisters decided to drown the boy.  After they threw him in the river a bird flew up and sang of their doom.

When the king came back, the sisters said “the Queen had been delivered of a dog.” The king wrote it off as God’s will.

But the boy didn’t drown, and was found by a fisherman.  Since the fisherman and his wife had no kids, they raised him as their own. 

This was repeated again a year later with another little boy, and again with a little girl.  This time, when told the queen had given birth to a cat, the king had her locked up.

Years past and the oldest boy finds out that he was a foundling.  So he sets out to find his real father.  After walking for days he came to a large body of water where an old woman fished.  He said she’d wouldn’t catch anything, and she said that he’d spend a long time seeking his father.  She then carried him over the water and he kept searching for years.

A year later, the second son set out to find his brother.  And the same thing happened. 

Their sister was worried for them and so also set out to find them.  When she came to the old woman, she wished her luck fishing.  This was what the old woman was waiting for.  She then gave the girl a wand and some instructions.  The instructions were: follow a road, pass a big black dog without laughing or looking at it, come to a castle, drop the wand on the threshold, go through the castle, go to a fountain with a tree growing out of it and a bird in a cage on a branch, take the cage, grab a glass of water from the fountain, go back through the castle, pick up the wand, when she passes the dog again hit him in the face with it, and come back to the old woman.

The girl did all this, and on her way back from the castle she found her two brothers.  When she hit the black dog, it turned into a prince who followed them back to the old woman.  The old woman carried them over the water again, and then disappeared because she was free.  They all went back home to the fisherman and hung up the bird in his cage.

One day the second son when hunting, where he met the king.  The king asked him who he was, and the boy said the son of the fisherman.  But the king knew the fisherman had no son.  So he went to the fisherman who told him the story of how he found his children.  Then the bird in the cage sang of how the queen’s sisters had tried to kill his children.

They all went to the castle and had the prison opened.  But the queen was ill, so the daughter gave her the glass of water from the fountain which healed her.  The two evil sisters were burned, and the daughter married the dog/prince.


What’s the deal with the “bright red star?” It’s so important, it doesn’t come up again.

So these sisters decide – on a whim – to kill their nephew?

When they “kill” their first nephew, a bird sings of their doom.  So they decide to do it again.

I thought the whole, knock the mother out during birth thing was from like the 50s.  I mean, how else would she not know what she had given birth to.

The king never asks the queen why she’s giving birth to dogs and a cat?

I’m curious what story the old woman was from, what with this long list of specific instructions to break her free from a spell.  You’d think she would have needed the glass of water, but no, that was just … an added bonus the old woman gave them to save their mother?

I figured the dog would be her older brother and her other brother the bird.  But no, she just finds them on the road.  The dog is a prince and the bird is a … magic singing bird. 

So the king knows that this random fisherman has no sons, but never heard of how he raised two sons and a daughter?

So the daughter just kept a glass of water for … months probably. 

What happened to the other two birds?

So the dog/prince was just there so the daughter would have someone to marry?

No comments:

Post a Comment